Example

PCI: Named Decisions Can Coexist with Anonymous Reviewers

Peer Community In (PCI) evaluates preprints—publicly shared research drafts. Its general FAQ (publisher metadata: published 2021-06-16, updated 2026-03-30; inspected 2026-11-09; rule-effective dates unestablished) describes researchers checking drafts through peer review. A recommender (decision editor) collects at least two reviews, then requests changes, rejects or recommends. The Managing Board (oversight group) validates a positive assessment called a recommendation. The recommender signs it; reviewers may remain unnamed. After recommendation, reports, decisions and authors’ replies are public; rejected-work reports are not. Registered users can separately post signed, scientific, respectful comments; abusive comments may be withdrawn. These are general PCI process rules, not universal review requirements or measured evidence that identification improves accuracy.

0

1

Updated 2026-11-09

Contributors are:

Who are from:

References


Tags

Scientific Oversight of AI-Assisted Research

1Cademy