PubPeer: Moderation and Replies Are Not Scientific Adjudication
PubPeer hosts public discussion of research reports. Its undated FAQ is supplied as indexed text inspected 2026-11-09, not a complete live-page capture. Comments generally require facts, logic and publicly verifiable support. Personal-knowledge reports must use signed accounts, be supported as strongly as possible and receive case-by-case moderation; this does not guarantee acceptance. Misconduct allegations are forbidden. Moderators enforce posting rules and may reject unclear or obviously wrong comments. Despite this scrutiny, PubPeer disclaims scientific review and guarantees of truth. Authors retain a permanent right to reply through signed accounts. A convincing reply or paper correction does not automatically remove discussion. A posted concern is not a scientific verdict of error or misconduct. These are discussion rules, not measured resolution success.
0
1
References
Tags
Scientific Oversight of AI-Assisted Research
1Cademy